As Russia continues to use gas as a bargaining chip and Europe acts to reduce its historical dependence on Russian gas, prices are up more than 400 percent from this time last year. Instability and volatility are driving the market with approximately nine weeks remaining to fill Europe’s storage tanks before winter.
- Changing Russian strategies related to gas flows highlight its importance as a source of funds.
- Europe is uniting to reduce dependence on Russian gas as winter storage deadlines near.
- Market volatility and gas prices are expected to remain high due to continued instability.
For more data-driven insights in your Inbox, subscribe to the Refinitiv Perspectives weekly newsletter.
As every producer, trader and consumer knows, gas markets have been subject to constant, often overlapping, challenges during 2022.
Recently, ten days of planned annual maintenance of the Nord Stream 1 (NS1) pipeline caused limited supply to be reduced even further. Those hoping for higher flow rates when the pipeline came back online were disappointed.
Russia supplied gas at pre-maintenance levels – just 40 percent capacity – but only briefly.
Short-lived relief for gas markets
Relief at the restart – even at the reduced level – was short lived. Gas supplies continue to take hits even as concerns escalate about filling storage tanks ahead of the European winter.
Russia is now considering requiring payment in rubles for LNG exports after earlier threatening to cut off piped gas to any country that would not pay in rubles. Although full shut off remains a risk, it is not the only concern.
Only one gas-fired turbine (of eight) is currently operational at the Portovaya compressor station.
One turbine remains in limbo after being repaired in Canada. It is currently sidelined in Germany with both sides claiming to need paperwork or permissions the other has not yet provided. Three other turbines have been taken offline in advance of a planned overhaul, with three more offline due to stated technical issues.
On 25 July, Gazprom confirmed that gas flows from NS1 would fall by a further 50 percent to 363GWh/d (33mcm/d) starting 27 July, dropping terminal utilisation to 20 percent of capacity. And, although alternative export routes are available, industry analysts note that Gazprom is not using them to fulfil its export commitments to European customers.
Mission critical to both sides
The importance of gas to Russia and Europe cannot be overstated. In a recent speech in Tehran, Vladimir Putin discussed the commodity in uncharacteristic detail.
Russia continues to work with those countries who have not imposed sanctions, including China and India, to increase deliveries and sustain revenues.
On the other hand, Europe is working to reduce its historical dependence on Russian gas:
- On average, the EU has relied on Russia for 35 percent of its natural gas. To reduce demand, a proposed voluntary 15 percent gas cut for each member country (with some carve outs) was approved on 26 July. The vote, taken after Gazprom’s additional flow reductions, was nearly unanimous despite earlier opposition. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said that by acting together, the EU had “secured the strong foundations for the indispensable solidarity between member states in the face of Putin’s energy blackmail.”
- The UK is looking to reopen its largest storage facility, an aging asset that was taken offline in 2017 due to the cost of necessary upgrades. This is a direct impact of the war in Ukraine and represents the UK’s efforts to wean itself off Russian gas.
- Europe could source additional supply from Azerbaijan and Algeria. However, those increases cannot offset lost Russian volumes, making LNG key.
Concerns remain as winter season begins on 1 October, leaving approximately nine weeks for injections to fill Europe’s storage tanks.
Refilling them will come with higher costs given the risk of limited flows and substantial volatility, although LNG imports are helping. However, if Russian flows remain at 20 percent of capacity, it will prove challenging to fill inventories to the mandated levels.
Fig 1: Current aggregated northwest European storage levels vs. historical data
The silver lining of Russia’s gas maneuvers is to throw Europe’s need for energy independence into sharp focus, fuelling an acceleration of the energy transition and shift to more renewable sources.
However, even fast-tracked initiatives take time to come online.
As a result, we are seeing substantial growth in less renewable sources, with coal capacity and coal-fired power generation increasing globally to try and offset lower Russian flows.
Hopefully this will be a short-term solution.
Instability and volatility are driving the market
At the time of writing, price volatility reflects the level of risk and instability in gas markets and the likelihood that these conditions will continue for some time.
- On 2 August, the TTF Day Ahead is trading at €204 per megawatt hour (MWh), nearly five times higher than this time last year (€42/MWh).
- Following Gazprom’s 25 July announcement of further flow reductions, prices across the curve rallied. TTF DA closed at €168.6/MWh, for a daily increase of €6.06/MWh. SUM 23 extended its premium to WIN 23 to a record €15/MWh, further highlighting the risk ahead.
Figure 2 – Price volatility in gas markets
We expect prices to remain volatile and NS1 concerns to remain high: naturally, any updates regarding the repaired turbine will play a part in dictating price action.
At a minimum, until the repaired turbine is accepted by Gazprom and installed, flows will remain curtailed. Siemens stated the transport of the turbine could start immediately, so the ball is in Gazprom’s court.
It is unclear, of course, whether Russia will increase supply when and if the turbine comes back online.
Furthermore, the latest comments from Gazprom provided further indication that gas flows have and will continue to be driven by geopolitical factors rather than typical market fundamentals, ensuring volatility and sustaining elevated prices.
Europe will have to continue to import LNG at record levels, hoping that the latest 15 percent demand cut can help mitigate the loss of Russian gas flows and facilitate the refilling of storages to mandated levels.
Gas will remain a global bargaining chip
With gas export funds crucial to a Russia under significant, coordinated sanctions, Putin will continue efforts to control the narrative around gas supplies even as Europe takes unified action to reduce demand and protect regional interests as winter approaches.
Although it’s difficult to predict how, where or when this will end, we can expect that gas will continue to be used as a bargaining chip. While each side maneuvers, the market can expect to see supply risk, price spikes and market volatility for some time to come.