Strategy Note /

Chile votes left

  • Vote for body to reform constitution confirms decline of rightist governing coalition; short of 1/3 of seats for veto

  • General election in November 2021; leftist candidates scoring almost double the score of rightist ones in opinion polls

  • Mitigants of a shift left: splits in the leftist bloc, safeguards for orthodox policy, low FX risk, cheap equity value

Chile votes left
Hasnain Malik
Hasnain Malik

Strategy & Head of Equity Research

Tellimer Research
17 May 2021
Published byTellimer Research

The decline of Chile's right-of-centre, governing coalition, Chile Vamos, was confirmed by the 15-6 May vote to elect the body responsible for reforming the constitution. Its seat count in the Constitutional Convention is below the one-third required to block any reforms it opposes. Its 24% share compares to its c45% share of seats in both houses of Congress, which assembled after the 2017 election.

Chile's next general election is scheduled for 21 November. Incumbent President Pinera cannot stand for re-election and leftist candidates are heavily outscoring their rightist counterparts in opinion polls, by a factor of almost 2x in the most recently published one in March.

The investment case in Chile equities, particularly relative to LatAm peers, is underpinned by the tailwind in Copper commodity prices (Chile accounts for c25% of global output and reserves) and a well established tradition of orthodox economic policy. Chile equities, measured by the S&P IPSA equity index, are up 11% ytd and c50% in the past 12 months, in total US$ return terms.

The shift leftwards in politics is already evident in the laws passed to allow around a 20% early withdrawal from private pension schemes (indeed, the ruling coalition's opposition to these laws has likely cost them at the ballot box and in opinion polls), which obviously adds material risk to this thesis.

Four mitigating factors are the following:

  1. Orthodox economic policy is safeguarded to a degree in law: eg the Fiscal Responsibility Law of 2006 and the constitutionally guaranteed independence of the Central Bank of Chile.

  2. The leftist political spectrum of Chile is split across at least three coalitions, each made up of two to four parties, and this may hinder the legislative implementation of a radically market-unfriendly agenda: eg out of the leftist opposition in Congress, the Socialist Party, has merely c17% of seats across the lower and upper houses.

  3. FX rate risk metrics are relatively benign: the current account should see a small surplus in 2021 (0.3% of GDP, according to IMF forecasts), FX reserves are 7.5 months of import cover, and short-term external debt is merely 9% of GDP (according to IIF).

  4. Equities are already at a discount to history: trailing PB of 1.4x and forward PE of 13x are at 6% and 16% discounts to their respective 5-year medians.

Electoral decline of governing coalition Chile Vamos

Chile Presidential Opinion Polls dominated by Leftists

Related reading

Democracy disappoints in LatAm, May 2021

Peru unlikely to nationalise Copper, the key metal for renewables and EVs, April 2021

Chile constitutional can of worms opened but still attractive versus LatAm peers, October 2020